R91 练习: 七大准则详解
考纲范围
- Standard I: Professionalism — Knowledge of the Law, Independence & Objectivity, Misrepresentation, Misconduct, Competence
- Standard II: Integrity of Capital Markets — Material Nonpublic Information, Market Manipulation
- Standard III: Duties to Clients — Loyalty/Prudence/Care, Fair Dealing, Suitability, Performance Presentation, Preservation of Confidentiality
- Standard IV: Duties to Employers — Loyalty, Additional Compensation Arrangements, Responsibilities of Supervisors
- Standard V: Investment Analysis, Recommendations, and Actions — Diligence and Reasonable Basis, Communication with Clients, Record Retention
- Standard VI: Conflicts of Interest — Avoid or Disclose Conflicts, Priority of Transactions, Referral Fees
- Standard VII: Responsibilities as a CFA Member or Candidate — Conduct as Participants, Reference to CFA Institute
Q1.
Kelly Zhang, CFA, is an equity research analyst of Golden Finance. Recently, Zhang has a different opinion on a recommendation report with the group consensus and she believes her group members’ view is not objective. According to the CFA Standards of Professional Conduct, Zhang should:
A. attach her own independent and objective opinion to the group’s report.
B. not take any action.
C. dissociate with the current group.
查看答案与解析
答案:C
解析:本题考查 Standard I(A) Knowledge of the Law。根据该准则,Zhang 与其他组员的研究观点出现了分歧,且她认为其他组员的观点不客观(例如由于收受好处或受到施压等原因导致客观性受到了影响),那么根据 Standard I(A) Knowledge of the Law,她应当尽快脱离相关的违规行为,具体做法包括:拒绝在报告上签字、调离项目组、调离部门等。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ 如果一份投资推荐报告中出现2种不同的观点,会给外部读者造成困扰,也会对雇主形象造成打击,实务中也不具备可行性 B ✗ 根据 Standard V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis,只有当 CFA 会员或考生与其他组员意见不一致,且其他组员观点意见的独立性客观性未受影响、同样具有合理和勤勉的依据的情况下,当事人才可以选择将自己的名字保留在报告上 C ✓ Zhang 认为组员观点不客观,应尽快脱离(dissociate),如拒绝签字、调离项目组或部门 关联:R91: Standards I-VII — Standard I(A) Knowledge of the Law
Q2.
Jay Yuan, CFA, a newly promoted team leader in a financial analysis team, was confident in his financial knowledge and analytical skills. However, he lacked experience in team management and effective communication with senior executives and clients. Believing that high-quality investment advice could be provided as long as team members followed his analytical logic, Yuan did not spend any time in improving his management and communication skills in the early stages of his promotion. According to the CFA Institute Standards of Conduct, which of the following statements is most likely to be correct?
A. Yuan violates the I(E) Competence.
B. Yuan does not violate any standards as long as he maintains his financial knowledge and analytical skills.
C. Yuan demonstrates Professionalism by focusing primarily on his analytical skills.
查看答案与解析
答案:A
解析:本题考查 Standard I(E) Competence。该细则要求会员或考生需要在其职业生涯中不断学习和发展他们的知识、技能和专业能力。Yuan 虽然擅长金融分析,但作为团队领导,他还需要管理和沟通技能。他未能及时发展这些技能,证明他在新角色中缺乏需要具备的所有能力,导致违反 I(E) Competence。
选项 判断 解析 A ✓ 作为团队领导需要管理和沟通能力,未及时发展这些技能违反了 I(E) Competence B ✗ 虽然擅长金融分析,但作为团队领导还需要管理和沟通技能,未能及时发展这些技能同样违反 I(E) Competence C ✗ 仅仅关注分析技能是远远不够的,作为团队领导还需要良好的管理和沟通能力来证明其专业性
Q3.
Franklin Lee, CFA, a portfolio manager, works at Hahn Capital Management for more than 10 years and is planning to start his own business next month. Before his resignation is effective, he begins soliciting his current clients to whom he can continue to offer asset management services at his new firm. Lee also deals with the registration of his new firm in his spare time. Which of the following actions by Lee is a violation of the Code and Standards?
A. Soliciting his current clients.
B. Handling some registration affairs for his new firm before leaving.
C. Both A and B.
查看答案与解析
答案:A
解析:本题考查 Standard IV(A) Loyalty。在离职生效之前,CFA 会员和考生还是需要维护雇主的利益。Lee 在离职生效前招揽客户损害了雇主的利益,违反了 Standard IV(A) Loyalty。
选项 判断 解析 A ✓ 离职前招揽现有客户损害雇主利益,违反 IV(A) Loyalty B ✗ Lee 利用业余时间为新公司做工商登记并没有损害雇主的利益,没有违反 Standard IV(A) Loyalty C ✗ Lee 只有在离职生效前招揽客户这个行为违反了 Standard IV(A) Loyalty,注册新公司不违反
Q4.
James, CFA, a research analyst working in research department of an investment bank, just makes a decision to change his recommendation for the common stock of Blue Company, Inc., from a “sell” to a “buy.” He emails this change to all the firm’s clients on Friday. Just the day after the recommendation, Steven, one of his client calls with a sell order for 1,000 shares of Blue Company. Based on the CFA Codes and Standards, what should James do?
A. Give the customer the advice about the change in recommendation before accepting the order.
B. Directly accept the order.
C. Do not accept the order.
查看答案与解析
答案:A
解析:本题考查 Standard III(B) Fair Dealing。根据该准则,当客户的投资决策与推荐的投资行为产生冲突时,应该首先向客户提供适当的建议,如果客户坚持相反的投资决策,再按照客户的要求进行投资。
选项 判断 解析 A ✓ 应首先向客户说明推荐已变更,客户若坚持原决策再执行 B ✗ 直接接受客户的要求违反 III(B) Fair Dealing,应首先向客户提供适当的建议 C ✗ 直接拒绝客户的要求也并非合适的做法,应先提供建议,客户坚持则执行
Q5.
Jack Hoover, CFA, is a junior research analyst working in a research company, currently he is responsible for following Z Company. Based on the information he has accumulated, he believes that the outlook for the company’s new products is poor, so he plans to give a “sell” rating to the stock. During the morning tea, Hoover meets Steven Adam, a famous analyst, he has an opposite opinion about Z company. Hoover simply adores Adam’s profession, after returning the office, Hoover releases a “buy” recommendation to his clients. Hoover:
A. fails to distinguish between facts and opinions in his recommendation, then violated the Standards.
B. does not have a reasonable and adequate basis for his recommendation, then violated the Standards.
C. does not violate the Standards.
查看答案与解析
答案:B
解析:本题考查 Standard V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis。根据该准则,做出任何投资决策或投资建议,需要建立在勤勉及合理依据的基础上。Hoover 仅仅因为对于 Adam 的崇拜,在没有额外调查及信息支撑的情况下,就改变了原有的投资建议,违反了行为准则的要求。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ CFA 会员或考生可以根据个人观点做出投资建议,但该建议必须有额外的调查及信息支撑。本题中 Hoover 并不是因为没有区分个人观点和客观事实而违反准则 B ✓ Hoover 仅凭对 Adam 的崇拜就改变投资建议,缺乏合理和充分的依据,违反 V(A) C ✗ Hoover 违反了 V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis 关联:R91: Standards I-VII — Standard V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis
Q6.
Felix Zhao, CFA, works as investment consultant in Golden Finance. Recently a new client, Eric, switched his account from another investment advisory firm to Zhao’s firm. After spending a few minutes getting acquainted, Zhao recommends Eric to buy a stock that he believes is highly undervalued. Zhao thoroughly explains the characteristics of the company to Eric. Does Zhao most likely violate the CFA Institute Code and Standards?
A. No, since Zhao has thoroughly explained the characteristics of the investment to the client.
B. Yes, since Zhao should explain his qualifications and areas of expertise before making a recommendation.
C. Yes, since Zhao should determine Eric’s needs, objectives and risk tolerance before making a recommendation.
查看答案与解析
答案:C
解析:本题考查 Standard III(C) Suitability。根据该准则,会员和考生在做出投资推荐或实施操作之前,应该先合理调查清楚客户或潜在客户的投资经验、风险与回报目标,以及财务限制条件。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ 尽管 Zhao 向客户解释了投资的特征,但他应该事先了解客户的需求、目标、风险承受能力等基本信息后,再为客户做出合理的投资推荐 B ✗ Zhao 违反 Standard III(C) Suitability,是因为没有事先了解客户的需求、目标、风险承受能力等基本信息,而非没有介绍自己的基本情况 C ✓ 在做投资推荐前必须先了解客户的需求、目标和风险承受能力
Q7.
When a client asks him about how he makes investment analysis, Victor Garcia, CFA, replies that he usually draws his conclusion using mosaic theory. The information covered by his analysis is public and nonmaterial nonpublic information gathered from different sources, including his evaluation of statements made by company insiders in personal conversations, where company management discusses earning projections which are not yet released to the public. Besides, Garcia also includes in his analysis the general industry information which he gathers from industry experts. Garcia most likely violates the CFA Institute Standards of Professional Conduct because of his use of:
A. nonmaterial nonpublic information.
B. statements in personal conversations.
C. industry expert information.
查看答案与解析
答案:B
解析:本题考查 Standard II(A) Material Nonpublic Information。Garcia 从私人谈话中获取的信息的来源是公司内部人员(管理层),说明了信息的可靠性,并且这些信息是关于营收预期的,是重大且非公开的,Garcia 使用这些信息进行投资分析违反了 II(A) Material Nonpublic Information。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ 根据马赛克理论,Garcia 可以使用公开信息,以及非重大非公开信息进行投资分析,这不违规 B ✓ 从公司管理层私人谈话中获取的营收预期属于重大非公开信息 (MNPI),使用该信息违反 II(A) C ✗ Garcia 从行业专家那里获得的信息属于一般的行业信息,属于公开信息,并不会违反准则 关联:R91: Standards I-VII — Standard II(A) Material Nonpublic Information
Q8.
XYZ Asset Management runs a private equity fund. It charges fees for providing structuring advice to invested companies, with a policy to refund fees if the investment value drops. This arrangement isn’t disclosed in the fund’s documents. CEO David Beta justifies this as common practice beneficial to investors. Regarding to the CFA Code and Standards, which of the following statements is most accurate?
A. Beta does not violate V (B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients, because common industry practices excuse non-disclosure in this case.
B. By withholding disclosure, Beta violates V (B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients.
C. Disclosure of the fee arrangement is not necessary because it’s beneficial to clients.
查看答案与解析
答案:B
解析:本题考查 Standard V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients。该细则要求 CFA 会员或考生在与客户及潜在客户沟通的时候,需要全面、及时、完整地披露与客户利益相关的信息,包括将提供服务的性质及费用的安排。Beta 未将费用安排披露给客户,也违反了该细则的要求。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ CFA 会员或考生在与客户及潜在客户沟通的时候,需要全面、及时、完整地披露与客户利益相关的信息,行业惯例并不能作为不遵守 CFA 道德准则的理由 B ✓ 未披露费用安排违反了 V(B),无论是否为行业惯例或看似对客户有利 C ✗ 即使安排看似对客户有利,CFA 会员或考生在与客户及潜在客户沟通的时候,仍需要全面、及时、完整地披露与客户利益相关的信息 关联:R91: Standards I-VII — Standard V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients
Q9.
Dominic Diaz, CFA, is the chief investment officer at Sunflower fund management firm which is a well-established superannuation fund. The fund is well diversified and always uses external sub-advisors for its alternative investments. Recently, John Smith, Diaz’s high school classmate, left his employer and set up his own investment management firm specialized in real estate investments. In order to build up the business, Smith approaches to Diaz and asks him to refer some new clients. As the performance of Sunflower’s real estate investments has long been unsatisfying, Diaz decides to move the fund’s real estate allocation to Smith’s firm and also discloses the change of sub-advisors in the fund’s next annual report. Diaz’s actions least likely violate:
A. V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis
B. V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients
C. VI(C) Referral Fee
查看答案与解析
答案:C
解析:本题考查 VI(C) Referral Fee、V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis 和 V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients 三条准则的综合运用。虽然 Smith 有让 Diaz 帮忙推荐客户,但题目中并没有描述 Diaz 为 Smith 推荐客户,而是 Diaz 直接选择 Smith 作为他基金公司的 sub-advisor,因此这里并没有发生推荐客户的行为,也不涉及到推荐费。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ Diaz 可以选择 Smith 作为 sub-advisor,但必须深入比较 Smith 和其他备选的 sub-advisor,确定 Smith 是最佳选择。而 Diaz 并没有做到一个有理有据的判断就直接将基金的房地产投资部分交给了 Smith,违反了 V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis B ✗ 基金的 sub-advisor 变更对于客户来说是一个重要信息的变更,必须及时告知所有客户,而 Diaz 是在第二年的年报中才披露这个信息,没有做到及时披露,违反了 V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients C ✓ 题目中没有描述 Diaz 为 Smith 推荐客户,Diaz 是直接选择 Smith 作为 sub-advisor,不涉及推荐费,因此最不可能违反 VI(C) Referral Fee 关联: V(B)
Q10.
Julia Kate, CFA, is a junior research analyst working in Stone Securities, an investment banking firm. Stone Securities’ mergers and acquisitions department has a close relationship with Firehole Company, as Stone Securities has been responsible for all of Firehole’s acquisitions for the past 15 years. Kate has been assigned a task to write a research report on Firehole company. Based on the requirement of the Code and Standards of CFA Institute, what is the best course of action for her to follow?
A. Kate may not express any negative opinions on Firehole because of the close relationship between the two companies.
B. Kate should refuse to accept the task because the relationship between Stone Securities and Firehole Company.
C. Kate may write the report if the close relationship with the Firehole is disclosed in the report.
查看答案与解析
答案:B
解析:本题考查 Standard VI(A) Avoid or Disclose Conflicts。该细则要求,当存在利益冲突时,CFA 会员或考生应该努力避免该冲突,若无法合理避免,则需要进行披露。本题中,Kate 所在的公司与 Firehole Company 存在利益瓜葛,所以最佳做法应该是拒绝为 Firehole Company 撰写报告(若实在无法拒绝,则可以撰写报告,但必须在报告中披露利益冲突)。
选项 判断 解析 A ✗ 根据 I(B) Independence and Objectivity 的要求,CFA 会员或考生在做投资分析或建议时,必须保持独立和客观,不能被任何外部关系或利益所影响。仅仅因为两家公司之间的密切关系就避免表达负面意见是不合适的 B ✓ 最佳做法是拒绝撰写报告以避免利益冲突;若无法拒绝则必须在报告中披露利益冲突 C ✗ 虽然这个选项提到了披露利益冲突,但它并非首选或最佳做法。VI(A) 要求 CFA 会员或考生应该努力避免该冲突,若无法合理避免,则需要进行披露 关联:R91: Standards I-VII — Standard VI(A) Avoid or Disclose Conflicts